Tuesday, February 01, 2011

The Soi-Disant, Ersatz 'Scottish Government Gleefully Enslaves Scots In The Grand Manner Of Its 17th Century Heroes

'The prevalence of vagrants of divers sorts formed a distinctive feature in the social life of the nation for a very long period. In his "Second Discourse on the Affairs of Scotland" (A.D. 1698), Andrew Fletcher of Saltoun gives a very forcible picture of the state of matters in this respect, as known to him. At the date of his writing, the occurrence of three bad harvests in succession had no doubt made things worse; yet, says Fletcher, "In all times there have been about one hundred thousand of those vagabonds who had lived without any regard or subjection either to the laws of the land or even those of God and Nature. No magistrate could ever be informed, or discover, which way one in a hundred of these wretches died, or that ever they were baptized. Many murders have been discovered among them; and they are not only a most unspeakable oppression to poor tenants—who, if they give not bread or some kind of provision to perhaps forty such villains in one day, are sure to be insulted by them—but they rob many poor people who live in houses distant from any neighbourhood. In years of plenty many thousands of them meet together in the mountains, where they feast and riot for many days; and at country weddings, markets, burials, and the like public occasions, they are to be seen—both men and women—perpetually drunk, cursing, blaspheming, and fighting together"...Fletcher had the courage of his opinions, and he believed in thorough-going remedies. Therefore, founding upon the example of the "wise antients," such as the Greeks, he tells us he would have had all these lawless wandering people assigned in perpetual servitude to the owners of the soil and others. He did not doubt of his proposal being met "not only with all the misconstruction and obloquy, but all the disdain, fury, and outcries of which either ignorant magistrates or proud, lazy, and miserable people are capable." But they must pardon him if he told them that he regarded "not names but things." -
"A new law has come into force across Scotland which means low-level criminals can be ordered to do manual labour instead of serving time in jail.

From now on, courts will be encouraged to consider imposing a Community Payback Order as an alternative to jail terms of less than three months.

It means offenders can be tasked with removing graffiti or renovation work.

Labour said it was a "dark day for justice" but ministers said jail was the right place for serious offenders.

Justice Secretary Kenny MacAskill said: "But at the other end of the scale, we need to address Scotland's appalling reoffending rate for low-level offenders.

"These offenders are going in and out of prison, time and time again and committing more crime in communities upon release.

"All the evidence shows that getting offenders out doing some manual labour in the community works far better than short-term prison sentences and actually stops them committing further crimes."

Apart from making offenders work, payback orders will also allow courts to require them to undertake treatment to try to address the reasons why they have committed crimes.

The new system replaces community service orders, which have been viewed with suspicion by many judges and sheriffs." -

Labels: , , ,

4 Comments:

Blogger The Young Oligarch said...

Of course , Martin , the immediate predecessors of Andrew Fletcher believed that the very souls of their subjects belonged to them .

Thousands were sold into indentured labour in the Barbadoes , as many slaughtered for their beliefs and the whole country held in subjection .

You have heard of the "Killing Time" ?

Chain gangs for neds ? Great idea .

The rock pile at Peterhead with guards wielding carbines to encourage obedience ? Can't see what was wrong with it .

Time for the law-abiding to regain supremacy over the elite and their under-class allies.

A ! Fredome is a noble thing !
(Or however John Barbour spelt it ).

02 February, 2011 01:21  
Blogger Martin said...

Kepp taking the Thorazine.

03 February, 2011 00:23  
Blogger berenike said...

Don't see your problem with this (or at least the principle of it).

How's the book?

03 February, 2011 22:51  
Blogger The Young Oligarch said...

Thank you for your approbation , Martin .

I will inform my doctor of your diagnosis .

Helpful though it is , you don't address the point I was making , namely that Andrew Fletcher's policy represented progress from that which was followed a mere 10 years before , under the previous regime .

Secondly , by comparing current proposals to those of Saltoun , you seek to de-legitimise them and present them as archaic .

My contention is that the Revolution marked the beginning of the modern British and Scottish system . It marks a distinct break in the relationship between the ruler and the ruled . The passage of 3 centuries has not diminished this .

Lastly , the proper punishment of criminals is a necessity for a free society . Without such punishment , we are not free . I believe it often suits our ruling elites to be soft on criminals to curtail the freedom of the law-abiding . In doing so they seek a return to the pre-Revolution relationship between ruler and ruled .

My other personality seconds these remarks .

PS. Hope you are keeping well these days .

05 February, 2011 13:20  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home